Discussion about this post

User's avatar
GenCrit in N. California's avatar

Thank you for this wonderful article, though heartbreaking to read that the "great silencing" is happening as much in Iceland as here in the U.S. and elsewhere. It is truly frightening, that an extremely obsessed group of men and their captured, guilt-tripped devotees can have people of almost every profession and at every level of government in many countries terrified into silence, while demanding the most horrible physical abuses of cutting off breasts, genitals, and other reproductive organs, while poisoning their targets with dangerous hormones.

Every article such as yours helps wake people up and gives both validation of the problem and analysis of it, and hope to those of us working to end this travesty, that you and others are seeing and speaking up about this problem also.

Expand full comment
Mildred's avatar

Hi! Wonderful article so far, and no doubt it will be so to the end. For all of us concerned, it is very informative and important to hear news about the trans dilemma from all countries that are suffering from it. However, I just noticed something that is an understandable error... When you said the NYT wrote about the "transgender soul," I feel pretty certain that that article was referring to American "soul" music, not to the concept of the "transgender human soul," and the soul singer, Jackie Shane, who was "transgender" during the 1960s. It could easily be that the NYT writes elsewhere about there being such a thing as "the transgender soul," that is so fashionable (and bogus) nowadays, and it wouldn't surprise me at all, but I don't think that that particular article is an example of that.

It's out of admiration that I am writing to you about this, and also I'm coming from a work background of proof-reading! I read other writers' articles with a similar eye, not meant to offend. Also I grew up in the United States during the 1960s and loved soul music (never heard of that particular singer, though), so I have that familiarity with the topic. So please forgive me if this comment seems a tad bold or rude. In any case, all the best to you from your fan, Mildred

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts